Auto

Should I file a small claim?

Liability limits, deductibles, teen drivers and what actually happens after an accident.

3 minute readAuto

Quick answer

If the damage is close to your deductible, filing often costs more over three years of renewal pricing than it pays today. A claim history affects your rate and, in some cases, your eligibility. Report the incident, then decide with your agent whether to pursue payment.

What you need to know

Do the three-year math

Compare the net payment after deductible against the likely surcharge across your renewal cycle.

Always report injuries and third parties

Anything involving another person should go to the carrier immediately, regardless of dollar amount.

Not-at-fault claims are treated differently

Comprehensive and no-fault losses generally affect pricing less than at-fault collisions.

Common mistakes

  • Carrying California's minimum limits, which a single injury accident can exhaust.
  • Declining or under-buying uninsured motorist coverage.
  • Leaving a household driver off the policy.
  • Filing small physical-damage claims near the deductible.
  • Never updating mileage, garaging address or commute after a change.

When to talk to an agent

Talk to an agent before adding a teen driver, after buying a vehicle, after an accident or ticket, or any time you are not sure whether your liability limits would survive a serious at-fault crash.

Frequently asked

This article is general information, not a policy or a promise of coverage. What your policy pays depends on its specific terms, limits and exclusions. Ask us to review your actual policy before making a decision.

Still have a question this didn't answer?

Ask us directly. We'd rather explain it than have you guess.

Review My Coverage